Monday, March 31, 2008

Things I've Learned About Baseball While Writing This Blog


Some Interesting Things I've Learned While Writing This Blog

As I wrap things up at Depression Era Baseball, I thought I'd just list a few things I've discovered while playing this replay and researching the era in general (in no particular order):

1. While we tend to believe that player mobility is mostly a product of free agency, and that "in the good old days" most players stayed with one team, this doesn't seem to be true. While conducting my 1934 replay, I also replayed 1931. A great many players were on other teams only three years earlier. This didn't include only journeymen, but truly great players like Rogers Hornsby, Chick Hafey, Chuck Klein and Stan Hack.


2. Baseball players did not "work out" in the 1930s, or seek to develop their physique. At the time, it was thought to be detrimental to their flexibility, which was thought to be more important in a baseball player. This seems to be the mentality in Japan. New Royals' skipper Trey Hillman will reportedly use flexibility training as a way of improving his team's conditioning for 2008.

3. Boy, the Cubs had some great teams in the 1930s. They never won the World Series, so we don't hear much about them, but they won 3 pennants and finished out of the top 3 only 1 time in the decade.


4. The 1930s was the era of nicknames - the weird players were the ones that didn't have one.

5. The public persona of Dizzy Dean was highly misleading and a deliberate distortion of a man who realized he needed a "character" to sell himself. In public, he was a colorful country rube, who couldn't pronounce the King's English and couldn't care less. In private, though, he was a well spoken, refined family man and friend.

6. The 1930s teemed with great players, many of whom we are familiar. Many others, however, such as Lon Warneke, Chuck Klein, and Red Ruffing deserve to be much better known. Part of the problem is that there aren't a lot of books on the era. A new, comprehensive treatment of baseball during this era is definitely needed.

7. In response to the Yankees' dominance at the end of the decade, the AL adopted a rule prohibiting other teams from trading with the league champion of the previous year. The champion was only allowed to pick up player off waivers. This rule prompted NL executive Branch Rickey to remark, "They've gone communistic in that league. The rule was repealed at the All Star break in 1941 when it was clear that, without Hank Greenberg, the reigning AL champion Detroit Tigers didn't pose a threat to anyone.

8. The Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) has a fascinating biography project underway.





October 8th, 1934 - World Series Game Six

We'll Play Seven!
Rowe Dominates Cards on Mound, at Plate; Tigers pitcher yields 5 hits while notching 2 to send Series to final game

Tigers pitcher Schoolboy Rowe put on a clinic both on the mound and at the plate yesterday, ensuring a final game today at Navin Field. Rowe yielded only 5 hits and 1 run to St. Louis, while hitting a home run to send the Tigers ahead for good in the second inning.

Elden Auker will take the mound today for Detroit against Dizzy Dean, who will start his third game of the Series, for St. Louis.





Strat-O-Matic Report











BOXSCORE: 1934 St. Louis Cardinals At 1934 Detroit Tigers 10/8/1934



Cardinals AB R H RBI AVG Tigers AB R H RBI AVG

P.Martin 3B 4 0 0 0 .370 J.White CF 5 0 2 0 .182

J.Rothrock RF 3 0 0 0 .167 M.Cochrane C 4 0 0 0 .042

F.Frisch 2B 4 0 1 0 .250 C.Gehringer 2B 2 1 0 0 .250

J.Medwick LF 4 1 2 0 .393 G.Goslin LF 3 0 1 0 .208

R.Collins 1B 4 0 1 1 .625 B.Rogell SS 4 1 2 1 .250

B.Delancey C 4 0 0 0 .095 H.Greenberg 1B 4 0 1 0 .250

E.Orsatti CF 3 0 0 0 .333 M.Owen 3B 4 1 1 1 .333

L.Durocher SS 3 0 0 0 .130 P.Fox RF 4 2 2 1 .400

P.Dean P 3 0 1 0 .167 S.Rowe P 4 1 2 3 .250

B.Walker P 0 0 0 0 ----

-- -- -- --- -- -- -- ---

Totals 32 1 5 1 Totals 34 6 11 6





Cardinals....... 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 - 1 5 1

Tigers.......... 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 3 - 6 11 2



Cardinals (3-3) IP H R ER BB SO HR PC ERA SCORESHEET

P.Dean LOSS(0-2) 7 1/3 10 6 6 4 5 1 132 4.15 A1 D9

B.Walker 0 2/3 1 0 0 0 1 0 8 0.00 E1

Totals 8 11 6 6 4 6 1



Tigers (3-3) IP H R ER BB SO HR PC ERA SCORESHEET

S.Rowe WIN(1-1) 9 5 1 1 1 6 0 123 2.50 A1

Totals 9 5 1 1 1 6 0



ATTENDANCE- 27,362 DATE- Monday, October 8th 1934 TIME- Day WEATHER- Good

T- 1:55

LEFT ON BASE- Cardinals: 6 Tigers: 8

DOUBLE PLAYS- Cardinals: 1 Tigers: 1

ERRORS- F.Frisch, H.Greenberg-2

DOUBLES- B.Rogell(1st)

TRIPLES- R.Collins(2nd)

HOME RUNS- S.Rowe(1st)

STOLEN BASES- P.Fox(1st)

SACRIFICE HITS- J.Rothrock

WALKS- E.Orsatti, M.Cochrane, C.Gehringer-2, G.Goslin

STRIKE OUTS- J.Rothrock, J.Medwick, R.Collins, B.Delancey, E.Orsatti,

L.Durocher, M.Cochrane, G.Goslin, B.Rogell, H.Greenberg-2, S.Rowe

GIDP- P.Martin, H.Greenberg



Schoolboy Rowe delivered 9 solid innings as the Detroit Tigers defeated the

St. Louis Cardinals by the score of 6 to 1 at Navin Field.



Rowe(1-1) pitched one of his finer games as he simply was too much for the St.

Louis batters. He allowed just 5 hits and 1 walk in 9 innings reducing his

ERA from 4.00 to 2.50. Detroit had 11 hits for the afternoon.



The loss was charged to Paul Dean(0-2). He allowed 10 hits and 4 walks in 7

and 1/3 innings.



SCORESHEET: 1934 St. Louis Cardinals at 1934 Detroit Tigers

P.Martin-A1 A1:E/3 B1:G-DP/5 C1:G/31 *8*:F/8

43>1o



J.Rothro-A1 A2:Sac/24 B2:G/13 *6*:G/43 D2:K

>12



F.Frisch-A1 A3:G/3>23 *4*:G/13 C3:G/3 D3:Si





J.Medwic-A1 A4:G/63 B4:Si C4:Si D4:K





R.Collin-A1 *2*:K B5:L/4 C5:Tr>1# *9*:G/43





B.Delanc-A1 A6:K B6:G/13 C6:G/3 D6:F/8





E.Orsatt-A1 A7:W>b1 *5*:F/8 *7*:G/3 D7:K





L.Duroch-A1 A8:K B8:L/5 C8:G/13





P.Dean-A1 *3*:E/3 B9:Si C9:L/5

B.Walker-D5





J.White-A1 A1:G/53 B1:G/31 C1:Si *7*:G/43 E1:Si>1o





M.Cochra-A1 A2:F/9 B2:W>b1 C2:F/8 D2:F/9 E2:K





C.Gehrin-A1 A3:W>b1 B3:L/4 *5*:G/53 D3:W>b1





G.Goslin-A1 A4:W>12 b *3*:K C4:Si D4:G/31

1



B.Rogell-A1 A5:Si>2# B5:K C5:E/4>12 *8*:Do

13



H.Greenb-A1 A6:K B6:Si C6:G-DP/5 D6:K

43>1o



M.Owen-A1 *2*:G/3 B7:G/63 *6*:G/63 D7:Si>2#





P.Fox-A1 A8:Si *4*:G/63 C8:FO/2 D8:Si>2#





S.Rowe-A1 A9:SB>12 B9:K C9:F/8 D9:Si>2#

HR>2# b#







*** TOP OF INNING 1 ***

0 P.Martin 5-11 3 1 Base Error - 1B b-1

0 1 J.Rothrock 4 Sac Bunt 1-2 b-0

1 2 F.Frisch 3-12 2 Ground Out 2-3 b-0

2 3 J.Medwick 1- 2 6 Ground Out b-0

*** BOTTOM OF INNING 1 ***

0 J.White 1-11 3 Ground Out b-0

1 M.Cochrane 1- 7 6 Fly Out b-0

2 C.Gehringer 1-10 4 Walk b-1

2 1 G.Goslin 5- 4 4 Walk 1-2 b-1

2 12 B.Rogell 5-10 5 5 Single 2-H 1-3 b-2

2 23 H.Greenberg 5- 9 4 Strike Out b-0

*** TOP OF INNING 2 ***

0 R.Collins 4-11 4 Strike Out b-0

1 B.Delancey 6- 8 4 Strike Out b-0

2 E.Orsatti 1- 2 5 Walk b-1

2 1 L.Durocher 4- 8 3 Strike Out b-0

*** BOTTOM OF INNING 2 ***

0 M.Owen 3- 2 1 Ground Out b-0

1 P.Fox 5- 3 12 5 Single b-1

1 1 1 Stolen Base 1-2

1 2 S.Rowe 2- 3 7 2 Home Run 2-H b-H

1 J.White 4- 3 6 Ground Out b-0

2 M.Cochrane 4- 9 4 Walk b-1

2 1 C.Gehringer 3- 7 20 4 Line Out b-0

*** TOP OF INNING 3 ***

0 P.Dean 5-11 1 1 Base Error - 1B b-1

0 1 P.Martin 6-11 1 Ground Out Double Play 1-o b-0

2 J.Rothrock 3-10 11 5 Ground Out b-0

*** BOTTOM OF INNING 3 ***

0 G.Goslin 4- 8 3 Strike Out b-0

1 B.Rogell 4- 8 3 Strike Out b-0

2 H.Greenberg 1- 8 5 Single b-1

2 1 M.Owen 2- 7 3 Ground Out b-0

*** TOP OF INNING 4 ***

0 F.Frisch 4- 4 17 4 Ground Out b-0

1 J.Medwick 5- 7 7 6 Single b-1

1 1 R.Collins 2-10 11 1 Line Out b-0

2 1 B.Delancey 5- 3 3 Ground Out b-0

*** BOTTOM OF INNING 4 ***

0 P.Fox 6- 5 3 Ground Out b-0

1 S.Rowe 3- 2 3 Strike Out b-0

2 J.White 3- 5 3 Single b-1

2 1 M.Cochrane 1- 6 4 Fly Out b-0

*** TOP OF INNING 5 ***

0 E.Orsatti 5- 6 2 Fly Out b-0

1 L.Durocher 6- 7 15 5 Line Out b-0

2 P.Dean 3- 8 16 4 Single b-1

2 1 P.Martin 5-11 5 Ground Out b-0

*** BOTTOM OF INNING 5 ***

0 C.Gehringer 2- 3 4 Ground Out b-0

1 G.Goslin 1- 5 6 4 Single b-1

1 1 B.Rogell 6- 7 3 1 Base Error - 2B 1-2 b-1

1 12 H.Greenberg 3-11 3 Ground Out Double Play 1-o b-0

*** TOP OF INNING 6 ***

0 J.Rothrock 1-11 4 Ground Out b-0

1 F.Frisch 3-12 3 Ground Out b-0

2 J.Medwick 5-11 5 Single b-1

2 1 R.Collins 1- 5 15 5 Triple 1-H b-3

2 3 B.Delancey 1-11 3 Ground Out b-0

*** BOTTOM OF INNING 6 ***

0 M.Owen 5- 8 3 Ground Out b-0

1 P.Fox 2- 4 3 Foul Out b-0

2 S.Rowe 4-10 1 Fly Out b-0

*** TOP OF INNING 7 ***

0 E.Orsatti 4- 8 3 Ground Out b-0

1 L.Durocher 5- 3 2 Ground Out b-0

2 P.Dean 6- 7 14 6 Line Out b-0

*** BOTTOM OF INNING 7 ***

0 J.White 6- 7 3 Ground Out b-0

1 M.Cochrane 5- 3 20 6 Fly Out b-0

2 C.Gehringer 3- 8 5 Walk b-1

2 1 G.Goslin 2- 9 3 Ground Out b-0

*** TOP OF INNING 8 ***

0 P.Martin 6-10 4 Fly Out b-0

1 J.Rothrock 6- 8 3 Strike Out b-0

2 F.Frisch 2- 6 5 Single b-1

2 1 J.Medwick 1- 9 3 Strike Out b-0

*** BOTTOM OF INNING 8 ***

0 B.Rogell 2- 7 1 2 Double b-2

0 2 H.Greenberg 3- 6 3 Strike Out b-0

1 2 M.Owen 2- 6 3 Single 2-H b-2

1 2 P.Fox 1- 8 5 Single 2-H b-2

1 2 S.Rowe 5- 3 3 5 Single 2-H b-1

SUBSTITUTE P - Bill Walker

1 1 J.White 4- 4 7 3 Single 1-o b-2

2 2 M.Cochrane 5- 6 5 Strike Out b-0

*** TOP OF INNING 9 ***

0 R.Collins 6- 4 2 Ground Out b-0

1 B.Delancey 6-10 1 Fly Out b-0

2 E.Orsatti 4-11 6 Strike Out b-0